FantasyAGT: Once Upon A Time (OUT) was the first installment of the FantasyAGT series. Mikey, Luke, Pennies and Fuz served as main judges. Saf, Nerdy, KD, and Mike served as side judges.
After the last Quarterfinal Episode, Pennies left the panel due to personal reasons. Saf replaced him for the rest of the season.
Judge Cuts 1[]
- Navarro Cheer Team, Cheerleading Group [1]
- Lukas and Aaron, Teeterboard Duo [2]
- Matteo Lane, Stand-Up Comedian end at 3:36
- Nina Conti, Ventriloquist [3]
- Brothers of Dance, Dance Group [4]
- Alex and Felice, Acrobatic Dance Duo [5]
- Soul Mystique, Quick Change Duo [6]
- Harrison Vaughan, Contemporary Dancer [7]
- Muy Moi, Danger Performer [8]
- SandyRedd, Singer [9]
- Jordan Anthony, Singer [10]
- Ben Platt, Singer [11]
- MozART Group, Comedic String Quartet [12]
- Hyannis Sound, A Capella Group [13]
- We the Kingdom, Country Band [14]
- Freelusion, Multimedia Dance Group [15]
- Joshua Jay, Magician [16]
- Marwadi College Mimes, Mime Group [17]
- Rastafarian, Marble [18]
- Peter Buka, Pianist [19]
Judge Cuts 2[]
- David Pereira, Acrobatic Dancer/Aerialist [20]
- Barcode Company, Russian Bar Trio [21]
- EDP445, Stand-up Comedian (Y M Y Y)
- Ali Siddiq, Stand-Up Comedian [22]
- JK! Studios, Comedic Sketch Group [23]
- Freestylers Laguna, Hip-Hop Dance Group [24]
- Jade & Josh, Dance Duo [25]
- The Space Cowboy, Daredevil [26]
- STICKSTOFF, Percussion Group [27]
- The Surrealists, Illusionist Group [28]
- Jan Reinder, Mentalist [29]
- Mitch & Cally, Dog Act [30]
- Fatmir Mura, Sand Artist [31]
- Anthony Gatto & Kris Kremo, Juggling Duo [32]
- VoicePlay, A Capella Group [33]
- OneRepublic, Band [34]
- Demi Lovato, Singer [35]
- Katie Kadan, Singer [36]
- Avery Wilson, Singer [37]
- Max Boyle, Singer [38]
Judge Cuts 3[]
- Golden Stars, Acrobatic Group [39]
- Duo Destiny, Acrobatic Duo [40]
- Jaboukie Young-White, Stand-Up Comedian [41]
- B Unique Crew, Dance Group [42]
- Bonebreakers, Contortion Group (Y Y Y Y)
- Oge Armethus, Escape Artist [43]
- Karen y Ricardo, Salsa Dance Duo [44]
- Ruti Olajugbagbe, Singer/Guitarist [45]
- Josh Kaufman, Singer [46]
- Matthew Hashimoto, Singer [47]
- Dalton Harris, Singer [48]
- Alexandr Misko, Guitarist [49]
- Rainer Hersch Orchestra, Comedic Orchestra [50]
- The Koi Boys, Vocal Trio [51]
- Walk Off The Earth, Acoustic Band [52]
- Rebecca Herrera, Mentalist [53]
- Luciano Rosso, Lip Syncing Performer [54]
- Dundu, Giants of Light, Light-Up Puppeteer Act [55]
- Raymond Crowe, Entertainer [56]
- Anatoliy Yeroheen, Multimedia Dancer [57]
Judge Cuts 4[]
- Duo Air Skating, Aerial/Ice Skating Duo [58]
- The Kiriku Brothers, Acrobatic Group [59]
- Matt Rife, Stand-Up Comedian [60]
- TPM, Comedic Dance Group [61]
- Michael Cunio, Singer [62]
- Shake It Up, Singing and Dance Troupe [63]
- Sean and Kaycee, Dance Duo [64]
- Enrica Musto, Opera Singer [65]
- Duranice Pace, Gospel Singer [66]
- Vinh Khuat, Looping Singer/Instrumentalist [67]
- Uché, Singer [68]
- Daniele Vitale, Saxaphonist [69]
- DRUM TAO, Singer and Percussion Group (Y Y Y Y)
- Signe & Hvetter, Singer and Guitarist [70]
- Jarred Fell, Comic Magician (Y Y Y Y)
- Marco Tempest, Digital Magician [71]
- Kevin Li, Magician [72]
- BLACK, Yo-Yo Performer [73]
- Sirqus Alfon, Digital Comedy Trio [74]
- Alexa Lauenberger, Dog Act [75]
Wildcard Episode[]
- Alex and Felice, Dance Duo
- Soul Mystique, Quick-Change Duo
- Raymond Crowe, Entertainer
- The Kiriku Brothers, Acrobatic Group
- STICKSTOFF, Percussion Group
- Fatmir Mura, Sand Artist
- The Koi Boys, Vocal Trio
- Josh Kaufman, Singer
- Jarred Fell, Comic Magician
- Avery Wilson, Singer
- Joshua Jay, Magician
- Michael Cunio, Singer
Quarterfinal 1[]
- DRUM TAO, Singer and Percussion Group
- Sean and Kaycee, Dance Duo
- Michael Cunio, Singer
- Dundu, Giants of Light, Light-Up Puppeteer Group
- The Koi Boys, Vocal Trio
- Brothers of Dance, Dance Group
- Duranice Pace, Gospel Singer
- Nina Conti, Ventriloquist
- We the Kingdom, Country band
- Joshua Jay, Magician
- SandyRedd, Singer
- Barcode Company, Russian Bar Trio
Quarterfinal 2[]
- Alexa Lauenberger, Dog Act
- Ben Platt, Singer and Pianist
- Freestylers Laguna, Hip-Hop Dance Group
- Ruti Olajugbagbe, Singer and Guitarist
- The Surrealists, Illusionist Group
- Dalton Harris, Singer
- Matt Rife, Stand-up Comedian
- Demi Lovato, Singer
- Anatoliy Yeroheen, Multimedia Dancer
- OneRepublic, Band
- STICKSTOFF, Percussion group
- Duo Destiny, Acrobatic Duo
Quarterfinal 3[]
- Navarro Cheer Team, Cheerleading Group
- Katie Kadan, Singer and Pianist
- MozART Group, Comedic String Quartet
- Max Boyle, Singer
- Karen y Ricardo, Salsa Dance Duo
- Kevin Li, Magician
- Walk Off The Earth, Acoustic Band
- Matteo Lane, Stand-up Comedian
- The Space Cowboy, Daredevil
- Enrica Musto, Opera Singer
- Freelusion, Multimedia Dance Group
- Uché, Singer
Semifinal 1[]
- OneRepublic, Band
- Barcode Company, Russian Bar Trio
- Max Boyle, Singer
- Freelusion, Multimedia Dance Group
- SandyRedd, Singer
- Matt Rife, Stand-Up Comedian
- Demi Lovato, Singer
- Sean and Kaycee, Dance Duo
- Dalton Harris, Singer
- The Space Cowboy, Daredevil
- We The Kingdom, Country Band
- STICKSTOFF, Percussion Group
Semifinal 2[]
- Dundu, Giants of Light, Light Up Puppeteer Group
- Uché, Singer
- Duo Destiny, Acrobatic Duo
- Duranice Pace, Singer
- Kevin Li, Magician
- Enrica Musto, Singer
- Matteo Lane, Stand-Up Comedian
- Michael Cunio, Singer
- Walk Off The Earth, Acoustic Band
- Navarro Cheer Team, Cheerleading Group
- Ben Platt, Singer
- Alexa Lauenberger, Dog Act
Top 10[]
- Alexa Lauenberger, Dog Act
- Demi Lovato, Singer
- Dundu, Giants of Light, Light-Up Puppeteer Act
- Duo Destiny, Acrobatic Duo
- Freelusion, Multimedia Dance Group
- Michael Cunio, Singer
- Navarro Cheer Team, Cheerleading Group
- Sean and Kaycee, Dance Duo
- STICKSTOFF, Percussion Group
- We The Kingdom, Country Band